top of page

The Comparison Trap: Why Everyone Else's Life Looks Easier

Updated: Nov 4

Hands with blue nails hold a smartphone displaying a photo grid app. A keyboard and camera sit on a white fabric background, creating a cozy mood.

You are scrolling. Again.


Another holiday picture. Another career announcement. Another person your age who seems to have it all figured out.


A heavy feeling settles in your chest. Their success looks so effortless, so linear. Meanwhile, your own path feels like a constant, messy struggle full of wrong turns and dead ends. It is a feeling I know well.


I was stuck in this loop for a long time. It took me a while to realise that this feeling is not a true measure of my progress. It is actually a flaw in my perception. I was not falling behind. I was falling for a cognitive illusion.


Once I saw it, I could not unsee it. And it all comes down to two simple but powerful mechanisms.


1. The Highlight Reel Versus Your Raw Footage

It helps to start with yourself. Think about the last time you posted something online. You probably shared a victory, a happy moment, a finished project. What did you edit out? The arguments you had that day, the self doubt, the messy first drafts, the tears of frustration. You know you are doing this.


But here is the part we forget: everyone else is doing it, too.


So, without even realising it, you are comparing your entire, unedited reality to everyone else's carefully curated highlight reel. You are staring at their polished masterpiece while being painfully aware of every single flaw in your own process. You live with your own constant doubts, but you only ever see their final, projected confidence.


When was the last time you posted about a truly unproductive day, a major failure, or a deep seated insecurity? Exactly. And neither do they. The game is rigged from the start.


2. The Illusion of the Straight Line

Then there is the second part of the illusion. When you look at someone who has "made it," your brain naturally draws a simple, clean line from their start to their success. It seems so direct, so inevitable.


But what you do not see are all the detours. The rejected proposals. The failed projects they never talk about. The moments of sheer luck or the support network that caught them when they fell. You see their destination on a smoothed over map, the kind that shows you the route but not the rough terrain.


But you? You are navigating your own journey in real time. You feel every single bump, every wrong turn, and every storm along the way. You are comparing your messy, non linear, in progress journey to their clean, finished story. It is an unfair fight, and you were never meant to win it.


Your Actionable Takeaway: The Comparison Audit

So, what can we do when we feel that familiar tug of comparison? We can gather evidence.

Right now, think of one person you often compare yourself to. Do not overthink it, just pick one.


An example of a Comparison Audit worksheet. On the left, a list titled 'What I See' includes items like 'Her promotion to Senior Manager.' On the right, a list titled 'What I Don't Know' pairs these with questions like 'Is she stressed or burned out?', highlighting the gap between perception and reality.
A completed example of a Comparison Audit. It shows how to break down the "highlight reel" you see of someone else versus the crucial, unanswered questions about their reality that you don't have access to.

Grab a piece of paper and draw a line down the middle.


On the left side, write "What I See." List everything you see about their success. The job title, the holiday photos, the happy relationship. All the curated stuff.


On the right side, write "What I Don't Know." This is the most important part. This is where you list everything you cannot see. Their private doubts. Their hidden sacrifices. Their debts. Their insecurities. The arguments they had to get there. The support they relied on. Their failed attempts.


The right side is where the truth lives. It's not filled with answers, but with questions. This isn't because their life is perfect, but because you have no access to their private reality.

These unanswered questions are the entire point. They are proof. You have been comparing your reality to a fictional character, a character you helped create by filling in the gaps with their highlights and your fears.


The audit shatters the illusion. The person you've been measuring yourself against does not truly exist.


The only path that matters is your own. But once you've broken the comparison habit, the real question is: how do you start building a version of success that feels authentic to you, and not just a reaction to someone else's highlight reel?


To help with that, I've put together a free guide called "Your Personal Definition of Success." It's a practical guide to help you define what truly matters to you, so you can finally focus on your own journey.

The cover of the free e-guide "Your Personal Definition of Success" from With Whispers, to define what matters to you.
Your definition of success is waiting to be found. This free guide walks you through the process of uncovering what truly matters to you, so you can stop following someone else's map and start building a life that feels authentically yours. ✨ Download your free copy and start the journey.






 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page